We have to admit, we love our Disney merchandise.

We probably have way too many Disney mugs, t-shirts, and Minnie ears. But if you’re reading this, we’re guessing you have your fair share of Disney items too! So we asked our readers an impossible question: Which Disney merchandise item would you SAVE if you had to choose just one? Here’s what you said.

On Instagram, we gave our readers two choices, and they had to choose which merchandise item they would save if they could only pick ONE. More than 19,000 readers responded to our questions, and they were pretty divided on their merchandise opinions sometimes!

We started off with Disney Sippers…

…vs. Disney Popcorn Buckets.

Do you prefer the drinks or the popcorn? Most of our readers would save the Popcorn Buckets! 

65% of responders chose popcorn buckets over the sippers, and we must say we agree. There are so many fun shapes to choose from, and who doesn’t want Disney popcorn readily available all day??

In fact, so many people love the popcorn buckets that there’s a new line of merchandise dedicated to the popular snack. You can get a Disney Loungefly mini-backpack…

…Minnie ears…

…and even Crocs with a Disney popcorn theme!

Next up, we asked you to choose between pins…

…or Minnie ears.

And we were a little surprised by the results! 61% of readers chose Minnie Ears over pins.

Pin trading is super popular in Disney World, but we guess that the adorable Minnie ears are starting to take over. Are we mad about it? Absolutely not. In fact, we’re a little obsessed with Minnie ears ourselves, and who can blame us?

The next question we tackled was Disney mugs…

…or Disney tumblers.

Our readers chose to save the mugs! 61% of readers chose mugs over tumblers.

With SO MANY options to choose from, a Disney mug collection can get truly massive. Seriously, there’s a Disney mug for almost every character, movie, and event.

BUT we’re also not really ready to give up the tumblers. Especially when this beauty just came out with all the new 50th Anniversary merchandise in Disney’s Magic Kingdom!

These really are some impossible Disney decisions. Next up we asked if you would save Spirit Jerseys…

…or Loungefly backpacks.

The Loungefly Bags won out by just a little bit! 53% of readers would rather save the backpacks.

Like the Disney mugs, you can find a Loungefly backpack for almost any character and occasion. One of our favorites recently was this one that has a special pocket to hold your Minnie ears!

Combining TWO of our Disney merchandise loves into one? Yes, please! Our next impossible choice was between Disney Wishables…

…and Disney nuiMOs.

Which cute mini Disney plush did our readers choose to save? the Disney nuiMOs just barely won out, with 52% of readers choosing them over the Wishables!

Although the Wishables are pretty darn cute, the nuiMOs have tons of outfits that you can dress them in, which might have helped them edge out the competition.

Our last question had the closest results of all. We asked you to choose between Custom Lightsabers…

…and Custom Droids from Galaxy’s Edge in Disney’s Hollywood Studios.

Although it’s pretty cool to have your own Custom Droid, the Custom Lightsabers won out just barely! 51% of readers chose to save the Lightsabers.

The good news? You don’t actually have to choose! If you’re heading to Disney World, all of these souvenirs (and a whole lot more) are available for you to buy. Keep following DFB for more updates on Disney’s merchandise.

Click Here to Read About 10 Disney World Souvenirs We DON’T Regret Buying

What’s your favorite Disney merchandise? Let us know in the comments!