When it comes to dining at Disney World, you’ve got a TON of options. Want something quick and easy? You’ve got it. Something middle-of-the-road and comforting? Yep, that too. And if you’re looking for something upscale and luxurious, you can find that as well.

Earl of Sandwich

We recently stopped by an underrated Disney Springs spot — Earl of Sandwich — to try out some of their over-the-top cookies, and now we’re bringing you our FULL review. Is it worth a stop on your next trip to the Most Magical Place on Earth? Find out here!

Sure, you know that Gideon’s Bakehouse and Summer House on the Lake are famous for their cookies, but did you know there’s another, under-the-radar spot to grab over-the-top cookies at Disney Springs?! Earl of Sandwich is home to well, sandwiches, of course — but they also serve up a ton of different types of cookies. They urged us to stop by and try them on our Instagram (pull our leg, why don’t ya?!), and of course, we’re people pleasers — so we had to oblige!

We stopped by to try a few, starting with the Cookies and Cream Cookie for $3.99.

Cookies and Cream

We really wanted to like this, but unfortunately, it had the least amount of flavor of the three cookies we tried. It’s a sugar cookie base, as there are no cookies incorporated into the dough, only as a topping. This cookie would probably be more of a hit with kids, as the sugar cookie base is a sweet choice to pair with the cookies and cream. The cookies on top are surprisingly not stale-tasting, but the vanilla icing drizzle only contributes to the vanilla sugar cookie flavor rather than bringing out the cookies and cream flavor. At the end of the day, this is more of a vanilla sugar cookie than anything else.

Cookies and Cream cookie

Next, we tried the Salted Kit Kat Loaded Cookie, which is also $3.99. This one is covered in chocolate chips and KitKat pieces!

Salted Kit Kat Loaded Cookie

This cookie has a classic chocolate cookie style as its base, topped with KitKats and caramel. This is a decent cookie. It has a sturdy base with familiar flavors of brown and white sugar, creating a classic cookie with a new spin of caramel. The KitKats are unnecessary, though, as they are slightly stale and very melty. The cookie overall is a solid cookie that we think will be popular with kids and adults. Make sure to have napkins on hand for this one, as it gets melty quickly!

Salted Kit Kat Loaded Cookie

Finally, we tried the Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie for $3.99. This cookie is covered in icing and loaded with Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal!

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie

This was surprising in that it wasn’t quite as sweet as it looks! The icing is a cream cheese frosting, and the tartness of the cream cheese brings the sweetness down a level. The cookie itself has a good crumbly cookie texture, although it is so crumbly that it may fall apart as you remove it from the bag. Overall, this cookie was good; the only not great note is that the cereal on the outside is a little stale from being nestled in the cream cheese frosting, but it was still good!

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cookie

In the meantime, we’ll be on the lookout for more restaurant updates from Disney World and beyond. Make sure you stay tuned to the Disney Food Blog for the latest Disney news and more!

Every Disney World Change I’m Not Prepared For in 2026

Join the DFB Newsletter to get all the breaking news right in your inbox! Click here to Subscribe!

WE KNOW DISNEY.
YOU CAN, TOO.

---

Oh boy, planning a Disney trip can be quite the adventure, and we totally get it! But fear not, dear friends, we compiled EVERYTHING you need (and the things to avoid!) to plan the ULTIMATE Disney vacation.

Whether you're a rookie or a seasoned pro, our insider tips and tricks will have you exploring the parks like never before. So come along with us, and get planning your most magical vacation ever!

GET YOUR GUIDE NOW

Have you eaten at this Disney World restaurant before? Tell us in the comments!