And then there’s the food, which is where Il Mulino really shines. The menu is extensive, offering everything from antipasti, salads, and soups to pizzas, pastas, and hearty entrées. Whether you’re in the mood for a perfectly cooked dish of pasta, a flavorful seafood option, or something from the grill, there’s no shortage of choices here. You can even order family-style if you’re dining with a group, making it easy to sample a little bit of everything.

Il Mulino bread service

Beyond the main dishes, Il Mulino also offers veal, chicken, and fish options, along with plenty of sides and a tempting dessert menu to finish off your meal. And if you’re a fan of a good drink, you’re in luck because the restaurant boasts an impressive selection of wines, beers, and specialty cocktails. There’s even a lounge area featuring a wine bar and outdoor terrace, where you can sip on everything from small-batch bourbon to cognac or a signature cocktail.

Carpaccio Di Carne

It’s the kind of place where the atmosphere might not scream “must-visit,” but the flavors will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left. That’s especially important when you compare it to a fan-favorite like Via Napoli in EPCOT. While Via Napoli is often considered by many guests to be one of the top Italian spots in Disney World, Il Mulino easily rivals, and in our opinion, surpasses it when it comes to quality and authenticity. The only catch? You’ll have to leave the parks to experience it. However, you can even take a boat over to Disney World’s Swan and Dolphin Resort from the International Gateway at EPCOT, or you can make the 10 to 15-minute walk from EPCOT or Disney’s Hollywood Studios.

Tiramisu

So, who is Il Mulino perfect for? If you love high-quality Italian food, this is an absolute must-visit. It’s also incredibly convenient if you’re staying at the Swan or Dolphin resorts, making it an easy choice for a relaxing dinner after a park day. And if you don’t mind traveling a bit outside the parks for an unforgettable meal, you’ll likely find this hidden gem well worth the effort.

Rigatoni Con Funghi

On the flip side, it might not be the best fit for everyone. If you’re trying to stay within the parks or close to your Disney hotel, the location can feel a bit out of the way. It’s also not ideal if you’re just looking for a quick or casual bite — this is more of a sit-down, savor-the-experience kind of place. And if immersive theming is high on your priority list, Il Mulino may feel a little underwhelming in that department.

Il Mulino

Still, if your main goal is incredible Italian food, Il Mulino New York Trattoria absolutely delivers and then some. It’s one of those rare Disney dining spots that flies under the radar but completely exceeds expectations. If you’re willing to venture beyond EPCOT, you might just discover that the best Italian meal at Disney World has been hiding in plain sight all along. And for more Disney dining reviews, tips, and must-try spots, be sure to keep following us at DFB!