It’s ROUND 2 of our Best Gideon’s Bakehouse Cookie Challenge!
Gideon’s Bakehouse
Gideon’s is home to MANY delicious cookies, and sometimes it can be hard to figure out which is the best to get. That’s why we’re having a big competition right now over on our Instagram to find out which cookie is the best, and we’ve got our second-round results right here!
Out of eight cookies, we’ve now narrowed it down to four. First up was the Original Chocolate Chip Cookie against the Cookies and Cream.
Original Chocolate Chip Wins!
Unsurprisingly, the Original Chocolate Chip won with 73% of the vote. Can’t beat a classic!
Read our review of the Original Chocolate Chip Cookie here.
Next up was Banana Bread Chocolate Chip against Eternal Flameless, and Banana Bread Chocolate Chip is our winner!
Banana Bread Chocolate Chip against Eternal Flameless
The banana and chocolate cookie won with 70% of the vote.
Read our review of the Banana Bread Chocolate Chip Cookie here.
Third was Cookie Vorn Krampus against Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl. It seems like lots of people are fans of the Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl!
Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl wins!
The Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl cookie won with 66%!
Read our review of the Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl here.
Lastly, we had Coffee Cake against the White Chocolate Caramel Macadamia Nut — Coffee Cake was the winner!
Sorry White Chocolate Caramel Macadamia Nut
64% of voters chose the Coffee Cake cookie, and we can’t blame them!
Read our review of the Coffee Cake Cookie here.
So that means for the next round, you’ll be voting on:
- Original Chocolate Chip
- Banana Bread Chocolate Chip
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl
- Coffee Cake
Gideon’s Bakehouse
So we’ll go from four to two! Be sure to keep an eye on our Instagram stories to vote in our next round, and stay tuned to DFB for all the latest Disney news!
See the new addition to hot cookie hour at Gideon’s in Disney Springs!
Join the DFB Newsletter to get all the breaking news right in your inbox! Click here to Subscribe!
WE KNOW DISNEY.
YOU CAN, TOO.
Oh boy, planning a Disney trip can be quite the adventure, and we totally get it! But fear not, dear friends, we compiled EVERYTHING you need (and the things to avoid!) to plan the ULTIMATE Disney vacation.
Whether you're a rookie or a seasoned pro, our insider tips and tricks will have you exploring the parks like never before. So come along with us, and get planning your most magical vacation ever!
Which cookie are you hoping will win? Tell us in the comments below!
Our handy (and portable!) ebook guides make sure you get the best deals and can plan a vacation of a lifetime.
TRENDING NOW
We've found the best Disney gifts for your mom!
Disney made some BIG Halloween announcements recently.
Disney has filed two new permits for the Indiana Jones attraction coming to Animal Kingdom.
Stop buying this at the park when it's so much cheaper on Amazon!
Cast Member previews have been announced for two Disney World attractions.
Disney just dropped NEW details about Lakeshore Lodge!
Check out Columbia's new Disney collection!
If you're driving to Disney World, make sure to keep these laws in mind.
Your MagicBand+ dying mid-Disney day? Absolutely not. This tiny $10 Amazon backup could save your...
Here's everything we know so far about the 2026 EPCOT Food & Wine Festival!
Retro Disney shirts are taking over summer park outfits, and Amazon has a few that...
What's happening with the Haunted Mansion?
The Jamba smoothie bar at Downtown Disney is closing after 23 years.
Disney just shared a shriek peek at Halloween merchandise coming this year -- including exclusive...
Disneyland is bringing back four snacks for Halloween!
If you’re dreaming of shorter lines, easier dining reservations, and a more relaxed vibe, timing...
Disney Imagineering filed four permits for Monstropolis!
Want to know which quick service restaurants qualify for the Dining Plan in Disney World?...
We love Minnie's classic red dress just as much as we love red lipstick! Now,...
How did Connections Flower & Garden menu fare in 2026?