We’ve been making the most of spooky season by treating ourselves to ALL of the Halloween snacks around Disney World!

But, which treat is the very best of the best? You can vote for your favorite in our new spooky food-themed bracket on our Instagram. Here are the results from the end of the second round of the DFB Halloween Treats Bracket!

First up, we had the Fall Flavors Cupcake from Gasparilla Island Grill in a battle against…

…the adorable Not So Poison Apple Cupcake from Pinocchio Village Haus! Did the poisoned apple have you all under its spell?

Not quite! The Fall Flavors Cupcake emerged victorious with 53% of the votes!

Next up, it was a battle of the witches vs. Haunted Mansion fans! The Caramel Cauldron Cupcake from Good’s Food To Go had to face off against…

…Constance’s For Better or For Worse Wedding Cake from Liberty Square Market. And the winner is…

…Constance’s For Better or For Worse Wedding Cake! It seems the Haunted Mansion fans really came through on this one and secured the win with 60% of the votes.

Then, it was the ultimate tiramisu show down! Pumpkin Bread Tiramisu from Rosie’s All-American Cafe versus…

…the Halloween/Graveyard Tiramisu from The Market at Ale & Compass and Beach Club Marketplace. At the end of the day, the tiramisu champion was…

…the Halloween/Graveyard Tiramisu! Make no bones about it — this spooktacular tiramisu with an edible skeleton on top was the clear winner with 58% of the votes.

What screams fall and Halloween to you? Chocolate or pumpkin? This next battle put those flavors to the test. Could the Pumpkin Whoopie Pie from The Market at Ale & Compass…

…win against the Spooky Mickey Brownie from Roaring Fork?

Not this time! Chocolate lovers won the day with the Spooky Mickey Brownie taking 52% of the votes!

Next up, we had Beaches & Cream Soda Shop’s Pumpkin Spiced Butter Pecan Shake up against…

…one of our very favorites, the Pumpkin Spiced Waffle Sundae from Sleepy Hollow.

And the winner is…the Waffle Sundae! YUM. Will this treat win it all? Only time will tell!

We love a good Dole whip, but could the Horseman Rides Again Float from Sunshine Tree Terrace beat out…

…the Oogie Boogie Worms ‘n’ Dirt Sundae from AristoCrêpes?

It seems Oogie Boogie never loses a bet! The Oogie Boogie Worms & Dirt treat emerged victorious!

This next battle was between two absolutely gorgeous desserts. The Black Flame Candle Cake from Amorette’s Patisserie had to face off against…

…the Pumpkin Mousse from Le Petit Café.

And the winner is…the Black Flame Candle Cake! We can’t say we’re surprised! It’s an absolutely fantastic treat!

Lastly, we had to see whether the Poison Candied Apple from Trolley Car Cafe could win against…

…the Mickey Jack-o’-Lantern Rice Krispie Treat from Goofy’s Candy Company. 

We love you Mickey, but the Poison Candied Apple was the clear winner here with 61% of the votes.

Well, those are the results of Round 2! Which treat will win it all? Head on over to our Instagram and check out our stories to vote! Round 3 voting is going on right NOW! 

Go to our Instagram to cast your vote!

Which Halloween treat in Disney World is your favorite? Let us know in the comments!