We’ve been talking A LOT about glass slippers, pumpkin carriages, and fairy godmothers lately because of the new 70th anniversary Cinderella treats that have made their way to Disney World this week!

And even though we’ve been muttering the phrase “Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo” in our sleep ever since all this Cindy madness started a few days ago, we’ve pulled together our ultimate ranking of every single Cinderella treat currently at Disney World!

Which treat will be crowned the champion? You’ll just have to read all the way through to find out our Cinderella treat TOP PICK! Let’s start with our least-favorite…

8th (Last Place): Cinderella Cheesecake from Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort

Oh Cinderella Cheesecake, we had such high hopes for you! I mean, look how pretty you are! But your cheesecake exterior had a weird, runny texture and that Nutella ganache filling was like a solid mass when we cut into it!

We wish we’d waited a few minutes to let this guy warm up a little before diving right in. That would have probably helped the Nutella soften up. We really feel like this could have been a top contender if the textures were a little better because the flavors were solid! Try the Cinderella Cheesecake for yourself for $5.49 from Caribbean Beach Club’s Centertown Market and see what you think!

Read our full review of the Cinderella Cheesecake HERE!

7th Place: Cinderella Cupcake from Disney’s Polynesian Resort

At Kona Cafe, we found another Cinderella Cupcake for $5.99! This one features a yellow cake topped with vanilla buttercream, blueberry filling, sugar crystals, and a white chocolate glass slipper. We love how the sugar crystals reminded us of Cindy’s glass slipper and the cupcake tasted good, but otherwise, nothing special really stood out to us!

Read our review of the Cinderella Cupcake from Disney’s Polynesian Resort HERE!

6th Place: Cinderella Cupcake from Disney’s Contemporary Resort

We’ve seen SO MANY Cinderella Cupcakes march into Disney World this week! At Disney’s Contemporary Resort we discovered this version for $5.99 featuring a yellow cake filled with pumpkin custard, topped with buttercream, a white chocolate slipper, and a fondant pumpkin decoration. While we weren’t too away by the cupcake or icing, we ADORED the pumpkin filling!

Read our review of the Cinderella Cupcake from Disney’s Contemporary Resort HERE!

5th Place: Cinderella Cupcake from Disney’s Port Orleans — Riverside Resort

Read our review of the Cinderella Cupcake at Disney’s Port Orleans — Riverside Resort HERE!

4th Place: Cinderella’s Carriage Cake Pop at Disney’s Grand Florian Resort

We rolled into Gasparilla Grill at Disney’s Grand Floridian Resort to try their Cinderella’s Carriage Cake Pop, and we weren’t disappointed! The triple chocolate cake in this cake pop is SUPER rich. While the cake is very moist and yummy, the white chocolate wheels add a nice crunch to balance it out! Plus, this thing is HUGE and only costs $8!

Check out our review of the Cinderella’s Carriage Cake Pop here!

3rd Place: Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo Cake at Magic Kingdom’s Main Street Bakery

The Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo Cake is truly MAGICAL in terms of looks! It’s a citrus almond cake topped with a lemon-scented Bavarian mousse, filled with blueberry compote, and adorned with golden chocolate wheels. While we thought the flavors and looks were yummy, we found that there was much more jiggly mousse than cake, so it ended up not really being much of a cake at all.

But diving into this thing is a beautiful transformative experience! The mousse had a subtle, delicate lemony taste and the blueberry compote was a big hit with us! We couldn’t stop staring at this thing either! It’s quite the head turner! We got the Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo Cake for $6.99 from the Main Street Bakery!

Check out our FULL REVIEW of the Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo Cake HERE!

2nd Place: Cinderella Ice Cream at Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort

Pineapple Lanai is serving Cinderella Ice Cream, y’all! This beauty features vanilla soft serve, crispy chocolate pearls, and a white chocolate clock. It’s finished off with a little pixie dust…a.k.a. edible glitter! Totally worth the quick monorail ride to grab this little goody for $5.99!

Read our FULL REVIEW of the Cinderella Ice Cream HERE! 

1st Place (BIG WINNER!!!): Greedy Gus Gus Cupcake at Disney’s All-Stars Movies Resort

Yesterday we fell in love with the new Greedy Gus Gus Cupcake. It features a rich, chocolatey cake topped with a chocolate buttercream frosting. Plus he’s stuffed with a marshmallow cream filling! Find him hanging around All-Stars Movies for $5.99! We ADORE the hat, the cheese, the ears, and the fact that this cupcake is SO different from the rest. Annnnd to top it all off, it’s totally delicious!

Read our FULL REVIEW of the Greedy Gus Gus Cupcake HERE!

If you’re excited to try any of these new Cinderella-inspired eats, you better hurry! We expect they’ll all be turning into pumpkins very soon and vanishing, so best be on your way! Just hold on to your glass slippers! And if anymore Cinderella treats magically appear around Walt Disney World, we will be sure to let you know!

Have you tried any of these new Cinderella treats yet? Which ones made the top of your list? Let us know in the comments below!